Get your free quote in 60 seconds — no pressure, no commitment.
Get a Free QuoteWyatt Mace is the founder and CEO of The Mace Agencies, the #1 Allstate agency in New Mexico and the surrounding region and one of the top-performing Allstate agencies in the country. Since 2018 he has grown it from a single Farmington office into an award-winning organization with nearly 20 insurance professionals, approximately 18,000 policies in force, and nearly $40 million in annual written premium.
Wyatt Mace didn't move here to sell insurance. He was born and raised in Farmington and opened his Allstate agency here in 2018, insuring the same community he grew up in. It's also where he and his wife, Karissa, are raising their three daughters.
Through organic growth, strategic acquisitions, and a relentless focus on building a high-performing sales and service organization, Wyatt and his team have built The Mace Agencies into an award-winning agency recognized among Allstate's top performers nationwide. Today, a team of nearly 20 sales professionals, service specialists, and leaders works together to serve thousands of customers across New Mexico.
Despite its size, the philosophy behind the agency remains the same as it was when Wyatt opened the doors in Farmington in 2018: hire great people, take care of customers, continually improve, and never allow growth to replace the personal service of a local agency.
Wyatt's background runs wider than most agents'. Before and alongside the agency he worked as both an insurance agent and a mortgage broker, and he's an Allstate Personal Financial Representative — which means the conversation doesn't have to stop at the car and the house. Protecting what a family owns and planning what it's building are the same conversation here.
Wyatt Mace
Founder & CEO · Licensed AgentI look forward to helping families like yours protect the things that are important — your family, home, finances, vehicles, and more.
— Wyatt Mace, Founder & CEO
Born and raised in Farmington, New Mexico, Wyatt Mace is the founder and CEO of The Mace Agencies (Wyatt Mace Agency Inc), the #1 Allstate agency in New Mexico and the surrounding region and one of the top-performing Allstate agencies in the country.
Since opening his first agency in 2018, Wyatt and his team have grown The Mace Agencies from a single Farmington office into an award-winning insurance organization with locations in Farmington and Albuquerque, nearly 20 insurance professionals, approximately 18,000 policies in force, and nearly $40 million in annual written premium.
Entrepreneurial roots. Long before building one of the country's leading Allstate agencies, Wyatt's career began in health and fitness. He worked as a personal trainer and certified nutritionist and helped operate and manage commercial gyms and GNC retail locations. Those early experiences shaped an approach to leadership centered around coaching, accountability, goal setting, and developing people, principles that remain central to how he leads the agency today. His career later expanded into mortgage lending, insurance, and financial services, and he is also a seasoned real estate investor with years of experience acquiring, owning, and managing properties throughout Farmington and Durango, Colorado.
Helping build better agencies nationwide. Wyatt is actively involved with C8, a national community of high-performing Allstate agency owners focused on collaboration, innovation, education, and raising the standard of agency ownership. He coaches and consults with agency owners across the country on sales, acquisitions, compensation, leadership, recruiting, operations, and growth, and helps organize and lead the C8 Conference.
Wyatt is also an Allstate Personal Financial Representative through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, so the agency's work extends past property coverage into life insurance and financial protection. He's insurance licensed across New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona, Utah, and Texas.
Local roots, national standards. Farmington isn't simply where Wyatt opened his first agency. It's home. It's where he was born and raised, where he built his businesses, where he invests in real estate, and where he and his wife, Karissa, are raising their three daughters. Read Wyatt's full story →
We're not a call center, and you're not routed to whoever picks up first. When you call The Mace Agencies you get a licensed local team that knows your file — in Farmington and in Albuquerque — and the same people the next time you call.
The #1 Allstate agency in New Mexico and the surrounding region, and one of the top performers in the country: approximately 18,000 policies in force and nearly $40 million in annual written premium, grown from a single Farmington office.
A 4.8 rating across 116 Google reviews, and the pattern in them is consistent. People name the person who helped them, because the same people answer every time.
Wyatt is an Allstate Personal Financial Representative through Allstate Financial Services, LLC, so life insurance and financial protection are part of the conversation, not a referral to someone else.
We're not a call center and we're not a comparison site. Here's the difference that makes.
Wyatt was born and raised in Farmington and has lived here his whole life. When you describe your street, your commute, or the hailstorm last spring, you're talking to someone who was there for it.
Farmington and Albuquerque offices, licensed across New Mexico, Colorado, Arizona, Utah and Texas. Move within the Four Corners — or anywhere across those five states — and your agency moves with you.
You get the claims operation and financial strength of a major national carrier, with a local office that answers its own phone and knows your file before you finish explaining it.
We're after the most coverage you can reasonably get for the least money — a different goal than the lowest possible premium. Sometimes that means telling you your current policy is already fine.
Open Monday through Friday 9:00 AM to 5:30 PM in both offices. Call (505) 600-4678 in Farmington or (505) 600-4678 in Albuquerque and a person picks up.
Auto, home, life, the business, the bike, the boat — bundling policies earns multi-policy discounts, and we re-check every discount your household qualifies for at each renewal, not just at the sale.
Stop by 3280 N Butler Ave in downtown Farmington, or call us at (505) 600-4678 — answered 24/7, and we have text messaging too.
3280 N Butler Ave, Farmington, NM
| Monday | 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Thursday | 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Friday | 9:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
Farmington, New Mexico
A quick conversation with our team can uncover gaps in your coverage, bundle savings you didn't know about, and real peace of mind for your family. No pressure, no spam — just the honest guidance a lifelong neighbor gives.